
Are the rights of young adults respected when pre-trial detention is ordered?
In the paper presented at the National Conference of Doctoral Students in Law (Craiova, December 2025), I started from a question: are there situations in Romanian case law in which the right to liberty of young defendants (Art. 5 ECHR) is violated?
You may wonder why I chose precisely the category of young people aged 18–25. I firmly believe that this group is one we easily overlook, because they are no longer minors, yet they do not have the maturity we automatically attribute to adults. And studies show that those treated unfairly in proceedings are more likely to reoffend, so fair treatment is also prevention.
Methodologically, I analyzed 24 rulings of various types, delivered by Courts of Appeal, Tribunals and Local Courts across the country, concerning the ordering or rejection of pre-trial detention for defendants aged 18–25.
What did I notice while going through the rulings and comparing them with ECtHR case law? The Romanian standard is, formally, stricter than the European one. The ECtHR allows arrest on the basis of “reasonable suspicion”, supported by objective facts. Art. 223 of the Criminal Procedure Code requires more, namely evidence in the procedural sense, not just plausible information. A case that passes the ECtHR test may not pass the more demanding test of Romanian law.
National practice depends quite a lot on the offence in question. For violent offences and offences against public order, the outcomes are mixed, with no uniform practice. A systematic tendency was observed to order pre-trial detention for high-risk drug trafficking, human trafficking involving minors and organized criminal groups. For robbery, the tendency was towards milder measures. The gravity of the offence thus remains the dominant criterion, sometimes at the expense of analyzing the young person’s profile.
We can say that in the first phase pre-trial detention is ordered frequently, and at first glance it may look like excessive zeal, especially where mitigating factors such as young age, no prior record or a non-violent context are present. On closer analysis, however, in many cases the measure was justified by the gravity of the offence and by concrete risks to public order or to the proper conduct of the trial. The system ultimately meets the European standard. What could still be improved is that the proportionality test be applied just as rigorously from the very first step.
In the paper, I started from the premise that I would find more violations of the right to liberty. The surprise, at least with regard to the rulings I reviewed, is that the hypothesis was not confirmed. I consider that around 85% of them were correct and proportionately ordered, in view of the gravity of the offence, criminal history, family environment, personal factors and the age of the young person. Let us return to the studies on recidivism mentioned at the beginning. If, in general, the right to liberty was not violated in these cases, then, at least in theory, such a violation does not appear as a risk factor for reoffending among these young people. With one caveat, however, because the studies concern the young person’s perception of the fairness of the procedure, not only its objective reality. And the perception of what is just or unjust, in relation to one’s own situation, remains subjective, which could constitute a future line of research.
Bărăgan, B. (2026). Analysis of national case law on respect for the fundamental rights of young people in criminal proceedings. In G. L. Gîrleșteanu (coord.), Protecția drepturilor omului în dreptul public și dreptul privat. Studii doctorale Vol. VIII (pp. 262–274). Editura Universitaria.




